Jump to content

Truth or Consequences

Recommended Posts

Truth or Consequences

Robert M. Blumm, PA, DFAAPA, PA-C Emeritus

PA Advisor to CM&F Group

The Bible records a Roman governor, Pontius Pilate, inquiring of a man who was brought before him for judgement. He asked Jesus: “What is truth?” To many, truth is akin to the spectrum of the rainbow with many interpretations. What is truth in our profession when it relates to providing care and counseling to our patients? There is an assumption, as healthcare providers that we will not lie concerning disease or prognosis. We are trusted PAs. The Oxford English Dictionary defines truth as a belief that is considered accurate and factual. Based upon this definition, does a physician or PA or NP have an obligation to be truthful or can they “shade the truth” to a patient?

The Charter on Medical Professionalism, endorsed by more than one hundred professional groups worldwide, and the US Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education require openness and honesty in physician communications. One can and should not expect less from PAs or NPs. Why is lying wrong? It endangers and is an abuse of patient trust. Trust is essential to the relationship that we build with our patients. The most important tool in your medical bag should be character, as demonstrated by your virtue and your honesty.

There have been national studies with physicians on this subject and, without outlining the many details, the conclusion is stark: MDs can do better. You can construct your comments with positive percentages and honesty, which states that we will work together to do everything in our abilities to treat a present illness. But you cannot sugarcoat a prognosis to give undue hope to the patient or family. There is evidence-based practice and reality-based practice; both are partners on the dance floor.

I proposed a question on Physician Assistant.com asking PAs, whether it is ever ethically responsible to lie to your patient. A majority of the responses were a flat and short “lying to the patient - never.” A PA in Texas had a patient who had had a stroke two years prior; the man had not walked since. When asked if he was ever going to walk again, the PA replied, “Never.” The wife was furious because she felt that the PA had deprived them of hope, despite his answer being honest, simple and polite. The patient had to know, that when the PA tells him something, it is the truth. Otherwise, he would not be able to trust anything that the PA said or did. As a healthcare provider, you may choose not to reveal the entire differential diagnosis with the goal of alleviating stress. But to offer paternalistic statements, one PA said, is just plain bad. There are some “nevers” in our world that are not only wrong, but could lead to litigation. Never tell a patient that they have cancer without a biopsy. A smart, experienced PA related that the manner in which you present a potential diagnosis - without lying or giving false hope - is the art of medicine and patient care.

I have seen patients with pancreatic cancer expire in a month and I have seen others live fruitful lives, re-creating their relationships, and living for four years. There are no absolutes when giving a prognosis, but we must share what we know to be clinically correct, as well as offer hope. Rather than play the part of the Grim Reaper, we have the ability to, as Maya Angelou writes, “Be a rainbow in someone’s cloud.” Trust is gained in small steps with each encounter, but when trust is violated it runs away as fast as a locomotive. Trust is sacred for a PA and their patient.

Trust is accountability when we are speaking of the relationship between a PA and their patient. And accountability means credibility. If we lose our credibility, what are the consequences? Lack of credibility and trust invites scrutiny and becomes a barrier that can result in anger, frustration and action. That action can easily become litigation because of a medical error, a prescribing error, poor communication, or a failure to diagnose or to treat. Behind that litigation is often a person who feels violated by a healthcare worker whom they thought they could trust.

Should this problem ever come knocking on your door, it is of tremendous value and comfort to know that there is a company that you can trust to defend your interests. Personal Liability Insurance is a must for active professionals and CM&F Group has been developing and providing such coverage for over seventy years and is endorsed by the AAPA. CM&F’s policy is underwritten by the Medical Protective Company, who enjoys the A.M. Best Company’s highest rating for financial strength - A++ (Superior). For more information please contact CM&F at info@CM&F.com.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The reason we are practicing in front of a patient is because of that patient, so lying to them never made sense to me, even as a nurse. Learning to sidestep and redirect is a good skill. Most of the time I’ve seen that the temptation to lie is rooted in making my own life easier in the moment vs. really having the patient’s wellbeing at the forefront. Telling the truth often involves a lot more work. If honesty is part of who you are, you’ve often organized your life to accommodate that reality. Case in point, my impeccably honest spouse, who can’t lie to save a life, but somehow makes it through each day with no complications whatsoever. 

  • Like 1
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to the Physician Assistant Forum! This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn More