Jump to content

I’m not sure if being a PA is feasible


Recommended Posts

So I live in Tucson Arizona and my fiancé and I just bought a house from his father. I originally was going to be a Clinical Psychologist but the median salary to PhD/PsyD debt ratio is atrocious. I was speaking with a former mentor and internship director now friend who told me that I would be better suited to being a Physician Assistant and that therapy doesn’t seem to have professional fulfillment (based on my experience as a group cbt facilitator.) He is totally right, I believe that therapy is an immensely helpful tool in treating behavioral health conditions, I just don’t think I should be the one to provide said therapy.

My point is that Tucson does not have a school with a PA program. The ones in Arizona are all Northern or Central Arizona and I don’t think I could make living in Tucson and commuting work (the nearest school is a appx 6 hour round trip.) So I am not sure what my options are or if I can do this at all especially considering I only have 300 pce as a CNA and one prereq done (Gen Stats and Psych Stats.) I have been doing research and I really like the idea of being a Psych PA. I thought about the Yale Online program but as it stands I don’t think I’d be a competitive applicant and I live too far from Mesa, Glendale or Flagstaff. Would it be possible to do a post bacc to fulfill pre-reqs and boost my 2.9 GPA and get more PCE in order to apply to the Yale Online Program? I feel like banking on one school isn’t a wise idea? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

In general, you can take your prerequisites any way you want. You can take them a few at a time while you work at something that pays, you can do a post-bacc (but you don't have to), etc.

Reading between the lines, the reasons you give for changing career direction sound like a mix of financial considerations and the experience you had as a facilitator. You probably need to get more hands-on patient care experience now, if only to prove to yourself that you really want to take care of patients. You're already making a change from your original plan; use the chance to take classes and get experience with patients to build a little more assurance that you're going in the right direction this time.

Banking on one PA program is probably not a safe strategy. It sounds fairly likely that you will have to go away to PA school. I did that (only two hours away) and came home when I could, or else my wife (of 36 years at the time) visited for the weekend. In my case, I did the didactic year that way and was able to come home and do my clinicals from home. Our military gets deployed all of the time and this was no worse (tough tests sometimes but no one was shooting at me).

So, plan your prereqs so you can afford them and make some money you'll need along the way. Get patient care experience so you can be more sure of your latest career decision and to satisfy the requirements of many PA programs. And plan for a possible temporary move away for a year or two. 

Good luck.

  • Upvote 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

If you haven't already I think the first step would be shadow a PA, or two, or three! You want to get a full idea of what the profession is and be committed because it does not sound like it would be an easy switch for you. But really if it is your true passion- you may need to plan out a few years to make this big change. 🙂

I am also a post-bacc student and have not gotten into PA school so take my thoughts with a grain of salt.

As far as getting into a program - unfortunately I have heard from many people that it is just not realistic to apply to one school. They have SO many applicants and only take a very limited amount. A guy I shadowed who works here at a top hospital in my home state had to move to a different state for school. Even though the top hospital has a PA program and he worked for them for years prior to PA school (had great references) and an almost 4.0 GPA. He did not even get an interview, they are just not enough spots for everyone! You'll need to get great grades to bump up your GPA and likely apply to a good amount of schools.

Best of luck to you in whatever you decide!

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you so much for the responses I am going to add AT Still Arizona and California  to the list (I am originally from California so Santa Maria will be a nice change of pace from 112 degree heat with zero humidity) and Midwestern Arizona (my little brother lives near by) to the list with Yale Online. I think I’ll add NAU to the list as well since I’m already entertaining AT Still California. There was an alternative medicine school in California  with a provisionally accredited program near my hometown that I thought was strange. I’m also going to take the rest of my pre-reqs at my Alma mater and the local CC. I heard some schools frown upon the use of lower division course work to fulfill pre-reqs so I am trying to err on the side of caution. I’m also going to try and rack up like 1200 PCE hours as a CNA. Side note I am a transgender woman and I heard there was a really awesome Endo MD and PA team that do really good work in town, I think I might like to try and shadow them. Also, there are a few clinics in downtown that are completely owned by PAs so I am might reach out to them as well.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Good idea to add more colleges and more shadowing! There needs to be more diversity in health care so I wish you the absolute best. 

 

I took my pre-reqs that were 200, lower level mostly at a community college cause it was way cheaper. And then I took A&P at my alma mater so it was 300 level or upper division and also had cadavers. Focusing on getting As in that should really show you are ready for PA school! Hoping that strategy works for me...to be determined! 

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/18/2020 at 6:39 AM, AJRCS said:

So I live in Tucson Arizona and my fiancé and I just bought a house from his father. I originally was going to be a Clinical Psychologist but the median salary to PhD/PsyD debt ratio is atrocious. I was speaking with a former mentor and internship director now friend who told me that I would be better suited to being a Physician Assistant and that therapy doesn’t seem to have professional fulfillment (based on my experience as a group cbt facilitator.) He is totally right, I believe that therapy is an immensely helpful tool in treating behavioral health conditions, I just don’t think I should be the one to provide said therapy.

My point is that Tucson does not have a school with a PA program. The ones in Arizona are all Northern or Central Arizona and I don’t think I could make living in Tucson and commuting work (the nearest school is a appx 6 hour round trip.) So I am not sure what my options are or if I can do this at all especially considering I only have 300 pce as a CNA and one prereq done (Gen Stats and Psych Stats.) I have been doing research and I really like the idea of being a Psych PA. I thought about the Yale Online program but as it stands I don’t think I’d be a competitive applicant and I live too far from Mesa, Glendale or Flagstaff. Would it be possible to do a post bacc to fulfill pre-reqs and boost my 2.9 GPA and get more PCE in order to apply to the Yale Online Program? I feel like banking on one school isn’t a wise idea? 

Hello there!

Small World- I also live in Tucson and currently taking prerequisites for PA School.  Becoming a PA is actually my second professional venture.  I've been a Social Worker in the Medical/Healthcare field for 11 years so I'm basically advancing in the field of medicine.  Due to working full time, I'm taking several courses online.  The programs I plan on applying to all confirmed that they accept online courses from a Regionally Accredited Institution.  I plan on applying next cycle.. AT Still, NAU, 1 program in Washington, 2 in Oregon and 1 in CA are on my list.  

Best of luck in your decision.  Deciding on a career is definitely not something to take lightly so weighing the pro's and con's is wise.  Another helpful tip:  PA schools like to see some volunteer experience as well.  In addition, the Personal Statement (in the application) carries A LOT of weight when admissions committees decide whether to interview someone or not. They want to know a deep reason why YOU want to become a PA.  Hope this helps! 🙂

 

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
On 7/18/2020 at 6:39 AM, AJRCS said:

So I live in Tucson Arizona and my fiancé and I just bought a house from his father. I originally was going to be a Clinical Psychologist but the median salary to PhD/PsyD debt ratio is atrocious. I was speaking with a former mentor and internship director now friend who told me that I would be better suited to being a Physician Assistant and that therapy doesn’t seem to have professional fulfillment (based on my experience as a group cbt facilitator.) He is totally right, I believe that therapy is an immensely helpful tool in treating behavioral health conditions, I just don’t think I should be the one to provide said therapy.

My point is that Tucson does not have a school with a PA program. The ones in Arizona are all Northern or Central Arizona and I don’t think I could make living in Tucson and commuting work (the nearest school is a appx 6 hour round trip.) So I am not sure what my options are or if I can do this at all especially considering I only have 300 pce as a CNA and one prereq done (Gen Stats and Psych Stats.) I have been doing research and I really like the idea of being a Psych PA. I thought about the Yale Online program but as it stands I don’t think I’d be a competitive applicant and I live too far from Mesa, Glendale or Flagstaff. Would it be possible to do a post bacc to fulfill pre-reqs and boost my 2.9 GPA and get more PCE in order to apply to the Yale Online Program? I feel like banking on one school isn’t a wise idea? 

Wow a lot of fellow Tucsonians haha. The only PA schools in Arizona are Midwestern, NAU at the Phoenix Biomedical Campus, and ATSU. They are all in the Phoenix metropolitan area and are not 6 hours away. I would look up the addresses again since I’ve driven to the campuses multiple times from Tucson. 

Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, LivPA said:

Wow a lot of fellow Tucsonians haha. The only PA schools in Arizona are Midwestern, NAU at the Phoenix Biomedical Campus, and ATSU. They are all in the Phoenix metropolitan area and are not 6 hours away. I would look up the addresses again since I’ve driven to the campuses multiple times from Tucson. 

Wow I didn’t expect to see so many of us! You are totally right it’s more like 2/2.5 hours one way with bad traffic and like 5ish all the way around. Oh snap I didn’t even know about the NAU option I was under the impression it was at the flagstaff facility!!!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Would getting a weekday apartment an option you'd be willing to do then? For example, you have your house with your family on the weekends... then, you have a tiny house or mobile home near the campus for the weekday? I don't think a 6 hour commute to class is smart. that's all your studying time being burnt away. 

Also, I think that yes, you need to raise it to a 2.9, however I even feel that is sorta low for the bar set by students. I just got rejected from Yale and I had a 3.5 GPA with my last 60 units being a perfect 4.0. Given, it's all holistic, I think that you would need to raise it well above the "minimum" to be competitive with the others. This is on top of the fact that if you read the yale forum, the people getting in with lower GPAs (not too much higher than a 3.0), have been like rad techs for 20 years, military medic for 10, etc. So, low gpa should be coupled with a lot of experience... However, you should read the yale online forum to get an idea of what it's like! 

Link to post
Share on other sites
11 minutes ago, mands said:

Would getting a weekday apartment an option you'd be willing to do then? For example, you have your house with your family on the weekends... then, you have a tiny house or mobile home near the campus for the weekday? I don't think a 6 hour commute to class is smart. that's all your studying time being burnt away. 

Also, I think that yes, you need to raise it to a 2.9, however I even feel that is sorta low for the bar set by students. I just got rejected from Yale and I had a 3.5 GPA with my last 60 units being a perfect 4.0. Given, it's all holistic, I think that you would need to raise it well above the "minimum" to be competitive with the others. This is on top of the fact that if you read the yale forum, the people getting in with lower GPAs (not too much higher than a 3.0), have been like rad techs for 20 years, military medic for 10, etc. So, low gpa should be coupled with a lot of experience... However, you should read the yale online forum to get an idea of what it's like! 

Hi there just to clarify I have a 2.9 already. I am working to increase my GPA. I will definitely read the Yale Forum!

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 minutes ago, AJRCS said:

Hi there just to clarify I have a 2.9 already. I am working to increase my GPA. I will definitely read the Yale Forum!

Oh, I misunderstood! 🙂 Then yes, get it to a 3.2 and I think you'll be peachy. That's the lower average for most PA programs! There's another program online that I do know of! I believe it is UND ??? uni north dakota??? there's another one + yale! I know for sure there is 2 in the U.S. so that does open up your options a bit 🙂

If you're still interested in tiny house living let me know! this is something i'm really passionate about and will be investing into once I get into a program, so I have all my research ready. I think that you should consider it, an apartment, or on campus graduate housing with how far the commute is for most programs in your state... I know it'll be hard to be away from your family most weeks (just go home on the weekends!), but if becoming a PA is your heart and passion, then you'll do anything to get there.  

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Similar Content

    • By futurepa1998
      Do I have a chance?
      I’m struggling to decide if I should apply for this cycle or not due to my gpa and PCE. I graduated last august with a bachelors in biology. I’m 23 btw. 
      Cumulative Gpa before post bacc credits-2.98
      Sci GPA-2.65
      Cumulative gpa after post bacc-3.17 (32 credits)
      Sci gpa after-3.10
      Post bacc cgpa- 3.98 sgpa- 4.00
      PCE hours as a CNA~1500
      Medical assistant~ 400
      HCE as a Pathology Tech~ 1360
      LOR- one from MD that I worked with, one from a PA I shadowed, and one from a former boss
      Shadowing~150 hours 
      Leadership Hours~80 hours 
      Volunteer~150 hours
      Taking the GRE this month 
      My GPA was low in my undergrad bc of going through personal circumstances and recently learning that I have ADHD. After finding out my diagnosis I completely changed how I studied and I had an upward trend my senior year and during this post bacc.
    • By Kalebmi20
      Hello PA forum.
      After doing some soul searching, I decided on maybe going for PA school. I am only a 2nd semester freshman. However, due to many circumstances, such as adjusting to online school, and a 1 star professor, my first semester of college was a 2.5. I also was not planning on anything after undergrad so I wasn't totally motivated on acing everything. I am doing my best this semester to make up for that, and getting a 3.75 or 4 this semester is realistic at the moment since Ive bee working extra hard. I am very worried however that all of the hard work that will come in the next years will be for naught if my 2.5 first semester will weigh me down. I know I am capable of getting mostly As and Bs from here on out, but will my first semester be the bane of my PA school application? Will schools take into account covid college and and very bad professors who hardly knew how to operate education software? Will schools see the upward trend as a good thing? I also understand that my application will be looked at as a package rather than just GPA, so I have some hope, but this worry still lingers.
    • By TatiRenee
      Hi everyone! I’m Tati.
      I just graduated in December with my BS in Kinesiology. I had a low GPA, exactly 3.0.  I don’t know what my science gpa is but I can only assume that is low as well. I plan to retake O-Chem 1 ( I got an S grading for it Bc my school did the S/U grading in Spring 2019) & I plan to take Biochem this summer. 
      I just started getting patient hours as an Emt in December. Once the PA application opens, I think I’ll have about 500 hrs. By august, assuming I only pick up my shift hours & not OT; I’ll have ~1000 hrs.  I don’t have any shadowing experience & it’s pretty hard to get some now because of the pandemic. 
       
      im debating if I should apply this cycle with only the minimum hrs & a low gpa or should I wait, retake some classes & apply next yr? I’m very conflicted and don’t know what I should do. I know I want to go to Pa school but cannot decide on the timeline. 
       
      any advice is appreciated!
    • By Tarantino
      Hi, everyone. I'm a non-traditional student, wrapping up my associate's degree in psychology from a small state school (not a community college) in Georgia. This college only offers 3 bachelor degrees, which is why I would finish elsewhere. I was a student at Arizona State Online, but transferred to take my prerequisites and labs in person. All my science prerequisites with in-person labs for PA programs will be done prior to transferring to the next college for my bachelor's degree. Now that I'm almost done, I was originally planning to then finish my degree through ASU, but am now considering finishing it at my local university for various reasons. Here's the two options I have:
       
      Option A: Finish my bachelor's degree in psychology at my local university.
      PROS: Graduate with less than $10k in debt. Get hands-on experience in research. More than likely get a stronger letter of recommendation.
      CONS: It would take longer to finish. I would barely get by, working part-time and living paycheck to paycheck. I would have to devote more time to in-person classes, which would take away from my income and time to do other things. Less volunteer hours. ALL clinical hours will be in private EMS, so my hands-on experience and skills won't be utilized as much, as it's 95% mostly transporting stable patients.
      Option B: Finish my bachelor's degree in psychology at Arizona State University (online).
      PROS: Accelerated program and can finish in 1.5 years instead of 2.5 years. Work in 911 EMS, which means better hands-on experience and utilizing my skills more - I think this will also make me a better provider in the future. More time to work, which means more income. More time not in a physical class, which means more time to volunteer, which is less stressful since I also have more money in general. Still get to go graduate in person.
      CONS: Graduate with around $30k in debt. Weaker letters of recommendation. Little research opportunity. Obvious I finished my degree online because the college is 20+ hours away.
       
      Although it would cost more to finish at ASU, I could become a PA faster, which means it would actually be better financially IF I were to get into both at the same cycle.
    • By ChristianPrePA
      Personally, I'm gaining my patient-care hours from working as a Physical Therapist Assistant, but other great options are: EMT, CNA/CMA, RA, ER tech, Scribe, etc. I've also considered being a scribe, ER tech, pharm tech, and EMT.
      I made a short video discussing my picks for the "Top 5 PCE jobs for Pre-PAs / PA school.
      Let me know if I missed any. What are you guys doing to gain PCE hours? Any ideas/suggestions/feedback would be greatly appreciated!
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to the Physician Assistant Forum! This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn More