Jump to content

Recommended Posts

I'm a second time applicant and would love to get some feedback on my personal statement to submit for this round.  Thanks so much for reading/reviewing!  If you have a PS you'd like feedback on let me know in a comment and I'd be happy to return the favor. Part of me wants to shorten it a bit but I also feel like each paragraph is necessary to 'tell my story.' 

Suddenly, I’m enveloped into an embrace with an elderly woman; we maintain our stance for several minutes without parting. When we finally divide, I am held at arm’s length. The remnant of tears trace down the side of her cheeks as she speaks softly. “It will be okay, thank you.” Her words are reassuring, although I am unsure if they are truly allocated for me.

We had attempted to resuscitate her husband in the emergency room for an hour without success. It wasn’t the sudden loss of life that caught me off guard, but the magnitude of the heartbreak I felt for the woman’s family that continues to resonate with me. This experience is part of what has made me realize that providing care within my community drives my passion to become a PA.  

After six years of climbing the corporate ladder I came to the realization that I was spending the majority of my day agonizing about a bottom line rather than truly serving our clients. My position required hours of analyzing medical records in preparation for trial. I would become engrossed during my review researching patients’ diagnosis and treatment options. I received the privileged, behind-the-curtain, opportunity to discuss their plans of care directly with physicians during depositions. This experience made me interested in medicine. During this time, I also began volunteering with Habitat for Humanity, which is where I had the experience that inspired me to change career paths altogether.  

It was a blistering summer day and we were in the final stages of restoring a dilapidated home. My few short months of involvement with Habitat for Humanity were beginning to feel more fulfilling than my corporate. I was wearing a blue hard hat and Habitat shirt which was stained with streaks of grey paint from the day’s work. The home owner, Valerie, waved me over for a cold glass of lemonade which I graciously accepted. As I sat down to enjoy a break from the heat, she relayed the story of how she became the recipient of Habitat’s philanthropic efforts.

Valerie, a single mother with two smaller children, described her youngest son’s severe disabilities, which had left him confined to a wheelchair. She discussed the difficulty of maintaining a job while tending to her son’s full time needs. She went on to explain the many hardships the family had as a result of financing his costly medical treatment. The paint brush in my hand almost seemed to shrink in size as I realized how minuscule my contribution to the community actually was. That day, with Valerie’s story burning in my head, I returned home and enrolled in school to become an EMT. 

I could not have fathomed that I would pursue a career in health care, and it is due to my trials and tribulations since completing my undergraduate work that health care has become an interwoven part of my identity. During my undergraduate program, I became discouraged, pursuing unfulfilling majors in multiple career paths. I lost my way during this time and felt disheartened with my education. Since I ascertained my devotion to become a PA I have excelled in my prerequisite course work and contributed over 1,000 hours to the underserved within my community while maintaining a full-time job. 

While volunteering at Puget Sound Christian Clinic I began to realize the restrictions of my EMT license.  I lacked the education necessary to fully care for my patients that required ongoing medical treatment.  I was provided with the opportunity to collaborate with an interdisciplinary team and had my first interactions with a PA. My path to becoming a PA was illuminated after observing our PA’s calming demeanor when faced with managing patients chronic medical conditions while navigating difficult language barriers.  

Recognizing the limitations of my EMT license, I strive to assist my patients at a higher level of care and offer greater support to the underserved as a PA. I look forward to using what I learn in a Physician’s Assistant program to lessen the burden of health care expenses for individuals like Valerie and continue to connect to their families in my community in their times of hardship. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

General comments (don't take these too harshly/personally, just trying to make it better):

  • You're PS is too unfocused, and talks about way too many things in your life. Because of this, it doesn't really have a clear theme and is hard to follow
    • You talk about: 1) an ER encounter you had, 2) being disgruntled working at a job, 3) how you got initially interested in medicine, 4) your volunteer opportunity at Habitat for Humanity, 5) an excruciating long story about Valerie and her son, 6) how you had no idea what you were doing in college, 7) how deciding on pursuing the PA profession made you excel in your academics and your PCE/volunteering/jobs,  8 ) getting your EMT license, 9) how you felt limited by just being an EMT 10) experiences with PAs, 11) how you want to give better care for your patients which is why you want to become a PA, 12) a random last sentence about Valerie and how it sort of relates to your motivations for becoming a PA
    • Honestly no one is going to remember or have time to dissect all of these different directions that your PS is taking us. Furthermore, none of these elements connect at all in any way and it seems like they are sort of just "empty" words that don't have much meaning/weight. With that being said, it do
    • If your life story was a whole pie, only serve a slice of that pie, and only serve the slice of that pie that is relevant towards describing 1) why you want to become a PA specifically, and 2) why you would be an excellent PA. 
      • You wrote all of these words and I still have no idea why you are pursuing the PA profession specifically, as opposed to any other healthcare position (MD/DO/RN/NP/DNP/PT/OT) where you can also help patients. 
  • Critical error: DO NOT USE CONTRACTIONS (I'm, wasn't). This is a professional piece of writing that is going to be read by professionals.
  • Critical error: DO NOT CALL THE PROFESSION "Physician's Assistant", also DO NOT CAPITALIZE IT ALSO. It is physician assistant. You will get auto-rejected for this mistake/severely judged.
  • Generally it is just not a well-written personal statement and needs revision and more focus and needs to stick to the prompt (why you want to become a PA and why you would become a fantastic PA). That is all that matters. No one is going to care about some ER encounter/your volunteer experiences/your trials and tribulations/basically anything you write about if they have nothing to do with why you want to pursue the PA profession and how your past experiences have shaped you into becoming a fantastic future PA.
    • Note: this is not me saying that these personal experiences you have written aren't important in your journey to becoming a PA, I am just saying that at its current state, your writing does not exemplify/demonstrate why you want to become a PA and why you would become a fantastic PA.

More specific comments (let me dissect your essay):

"Suddenly, I’m enveloped into an embrace with an elderly woman; we maintain our stance for several minutes without parting. When we finally divide, I am held at arm’s length. The remnant of tears trace down the side of her cheeks as she speaks softly. “It will be okay, thank you.” Her words are reassuring, although I am unsure if they are truly allocated for me.

We had attempted to resuscitate her husband in the emergency room for an hour without success. It wasn’t the sudden loss of life that caught me off guard, but the magnitude of the heartbreak I felt for the woman’s family that continues to resonate with me. This experience is part of what has made me realize that providing care within my community drives my passion to become a PA." -Not impressed by the hook/story. Does not relate to anything else you said in your PS. Do not use contractions. Very cliche.

"This experience is part of what has made me realize that providing care within my community drives my passion to become a PA." -So non-specific and cliche, especially when this statement could have been applied to any other healthcare profession (MD/DO/RN/NP/PT/OT/etc.) You can provide care within your community by doing any of these jobs. So why PA specifically? 

"After six years of climbing the corporate ladder I came to the realization that I was spending the majority of my day agonizing about a bottom line rather than truly serving our clients." -Do not put any type of negativity in your essay. It just sounds like you hated your previous job. There are more tactful ways of addressing issues/difficulties you've faced in other professions. 

"My position required hours of analyzing medical records in preparation for trial. I would become engrossed during my review researching patients’ diagnosis and treatment options." -Sounds like you are copying parts of your résumé/CV, which is inappropriate for the personal statement, especially when it does not relate to why you want to be a PA 

"I received the privileged, behind-the-curtain, opportunity to discuss their plans of care directly with physicians during depositions. This experience made me interested in medicine." -Also part of your job description/résumé. Why specifically was this important besides that it got you interested in medicine?  

"During this time, I also began volunteering with Habitat for Humanity, which is where I had the experience that inspired me to change career paths altogether.  

It was a blistering summer day and we were in the final stages of restoring a dilapidated home. My few short months of involvement with Habitat for Humanity were beginning to feel more fulfilling than my corporate. I was wearing a blue hard hat and Habitat shirt which was stained with streaks of grey paint from the day’s work. The home owner, Valerie, waved me over for a cold glass of lemonade which I graciously accepted. As I sat down to enjoy a break from the heat, she relayed the story of how she became the recipient of Habitat’s philanthropic efforts.

Valerie, a single mother with two smaller children, described her youngest son’s severe disabilities, which had left him confined to a wheelchair. She discussed the difficulty of maintaining a job while tending to her son’s full time needs. She went on to explain the many hardships the family had as a result of financing his costly medical treatment. The paint brush in my hand almost seemed to shrink in size as I realized how minuscule my contribution to the community actually was. That day, with Valerie’s story burning in my head, I returned home and enrolled in school to become an EMT." -Way too long of a story. Also the story is super cliche and doesn't really get into your specific motivations for pursuing the EMT profession (let also the PA profession, which is what this essay is supposed to be about). This essay is not about Valerie, or her son. This is about WHY YOU WANT TO BECOME A PA AND WHY YOU WOULD BE A FANTASTIC ONE. Make it FOCUSED ON YOU.

"I could not have fathomed that I would pursue a career in health care, and it is due to my trials and tribulations since completing my undergraduate work that health care has become an interwoven part of my identity. During my undergraduate program, I became discouraged, pursuing unfulfilling majors in multiple career paths. I lost my way during this time and felt disheartened with my education. Since I ascertained my devotion to become a PA I have excelled in my prerequisite course work and contributed over 1,000 hours to the underserved within my community while maintaining a full-time job. " -Super cliche. Also way too many flowery/emotional/unnecessary words ("could not have fathomed", "trials and tribulations", "interwoven part of my identity", "lost my way", "disheartened", "ascertained my devotion"). Also do not list you worked >1000 hours in an underserved setting, that is very inappropriate for the personal statement. 

"While volunteering at Puget Sound Christian Clinic I began to realize the restrictions of my EMT license.  I lacked the education necessary to fully care for my patients that required ongoing medical treatment."  -Just being devil's advocate, but what happens if you are a future PA, and you do not have the education (for example, compared to trained MDs/DOs) to fully care for your patients because they are very critically ill with many complex comorbidities that you have not been accustomed managing as a PA since you've only got 2-3 years of education versus 8+ years as an MD/DO? Would you then go pursue an MD/DO so that you can get the full education/training to fully care for your patients? (I'm just being picky, but just trying to point out the cliche-ness of the whole "lack of adequate training/knowledge" aspect of any job). 

"I was provided with the opportunity to collaborate with an interdisciplinary team and had my first interactions with a PA. My path to becoming a PA was illuminated after observing our PA’s calming demeanor when faced with managing patients chronic medical conditions while navigating difficult language barriers." -You can also manage patients' (this is the appropriate punctuation, not "patients") chronic medical conditions by being an NP/DO/MD. This is not specific to the PA profession at all. You also can navigate through difficult language barriers as an interpreter, so why PA? 

"Recognizing the limitations of my EMT license, I strive to assist my patients at a higher level of care and offer greater support to the underserved as a PA. I look forward to using what I learn in a Physician’s Assistant program to lessen the burden of health care expenses for individuals like Valerie and continue to connect to their families in my community in their times of hardship." -PAs have limits in patient care as well. You can assist patients in many healthcare roles, so why PA? DO NOT CAPITALIZE physician assistant, and definitely DO NOT CALL US a physician's assistant. You can connect to families in your community in their times of hardship in many other roles besides the PA profession. 

So I have to keep asking you... why specifically PA? 

 

Anyways, hope that me overanalyzing/dissecting your current PS helps you come up with a better essay! Don't take any of these comments personal, they are mainly just thinking points/points of contention that potential readers in any ADCOM would think of when trying to deny you an interview to their program. Remember, they are trying to find any reason to deny giving you an interview, as there are many many competitive applicants! Good luck. Feel free to comment if you need me to elaborate on anything I've said (For reference, I got 9 interviews and I am going to my top choice this year)! 

(I also hope this helps anyone else trying to write their own PS as I touched on a lot of points that could be applied to other people writing their drafts of their essays).

 

Edited by scankidofhell
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I like reading stories so I was (somewhat) engaged with reading your personal statement. With that said, your PS has too many stories and honestly they are stories that do not answer the question of why PA. I would start from scratch and really try to hone in on maybe 1-2 themes so your PS can be more cohesive. I personally would take out the Habitat for Humanity story, being on the corporate ladder, and your undergraduate pathway. They don't add anything valuable (I don't mean to be harsh) to who you are as an applicant and a future PA. Also, the only bits that were about the PA profession was when you encountered one. Maybe expand on that experience or touch more on your EMT experience (maybe about skills, compassion, etc vs downright saying you couldn't really help the overall outcome of the patient). I can also understand your reasoning for putting the opening story but it doesn't contribute anything other than some drama. The amount of times I read PS openings with a similar story to yours, makes it boring and not unique. Additionally, have a conclusion that is STRONG and is able to tie in all of the themes you incorporate into your PS. The conclusion is more important than the introduction (at least in my opinion anyway).

 

Please don't take my advice personally! I went through many drafts (and weeks) before coming up with my final PS. Make sure every word and every sentence is valuable to who you are as an applicant and how it is applicable about why you want to be a PA. Be specific about the PA profession, otherwise what you write may also be applicable to any other healthcare position. Best of luck!

(For reference, I'm a first time applicant going to my top choice! 🙂 )

Edited by aba51

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi @smile4fun

You can send your PS over to my email acceptedPAstudent@gmail.com.

I am a first round applicant who's been accepted to multiple PA schools and more than willing to edit and review your PS. This also goes for anyone else reading this post. 

I do appreciate a small donation as gratitude for my time spent reading and reviewing your PS, as well as any kind words on my forum post.

Hope to speak with you soon,

Hailey

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Similar Content

    • By IsaiahRW
      Hey everyone, I am a recent college graduate (December 2018) and I have been interested in PA for about 3 years now and with my recent graduation I’m sure you all can relate to the panick of the uncertainty of my life that I just stepped into 😂.  I’ve mostly been curious about my competitiveness for this upcoming cycle (2019-2020). Here are my stats  
      Overall GPA:3.494 
      sGPA: 3.54
      Last 60 hours: 3.65 
      Side Note: I initially had a 2.8 GPA freshmen year and worked my tail off to get where I am now. After I transferred to a new school beginning Junior year I made 24 A’s to 7 B’s with no C’s or D’s.  I know schools take into account upward trends and if that isn’t one then I don’t know what is!
      HCE/PCE:By time of application will have have about 750 hours with 300 being a Home Health Aid and 450 as a PT Aide. For schools who do not have rolling admissions I will wait until about late July to apply so that would bring me to around 1000 hours  
      LOR: Gastrointestinal Oncology PA, DPT who is my supervisor at work, Chemistry Proffesor
      Shadowing: 100 hours shadowing Oncology PA, Family Practice NP; Oncology MD
      GRE: Verbal: 153 Quant: 150
      Volunteer Hours: Over 500hours through my fraternity,NAACP, and my own efforts. Mostly registering people to vote, educating minors on sexual health, March of Dimes, and various other projects me and my fraternity brothers could think of. I believe this will be the strongest part of my application. I have a ton of other experiences of volunteer/community service I could speak of but that would take hours to type out 😂  
      My personal statement will more than likely focus on my experience with the many different types of clients I have dealt with as a HHA. Going into someone’s home is a direct view into their life and lifestyle and the differences and experiences between each is so unique it’s jaw dropping. I’ve had some crazy experiences to say the least 😂
       
       
      I appreciate any feedback. Thank you all!
       
      *Added some updates so I decided to bump!
    • By teamrogers
      I need advice on how to handle a certain advisor at my school. There is a lot to this story but here is a nutshell: I'm majoring in Cell and molecular biology and this individual is the advisor for my degree. When I express my interest in PA school he shuts me down and makes me feel stupid for wanting to go that route (he discourages people from the medical feild even though this degree was designed for pre med and pre health students). I've gone to another professor to sign up for classes and when he found out he sought me out and said he is the only one who should be advising me. He told me I'm going to graduate in a year although that won't be enough time to finish my pre recs for PA school and when I say this he flat out talks over me and doesn't listen to me. This advisor has behaved inappropriately with me before and I have recognized him as a emotional manipulator. When I stand up for my self and don't do exactly what he wants me to do or I dont let him pry into my personal life he acts like a humongous baby and treats me like I'm a bad person. This creates an immense amount of stress and anxiety for me when all I want to do is just enjoy school and do well. I have to take 3 more classes with this person  plus a senior project but I have dread about it because of the way he acts. My school is so small that the way its designed, he's in charge of much of my academics because of my degree. I've even though about transfering schools because this feels so unhealthy but I don't want to run from a problem just because its hard. Any advice? 
    • By nmb123
      I have written my personal statement and mentioned that I am bilingual in English and Spanish. My native language is English, but I have taken 10 years of Spanish courses and would consider myself pretty fluent (I use my Spanish daily with patients in an inpatient setting). Has anyone who has had past interviews, and is bilingual, been given an interview question in their second language? This could just be pre-application anxiety, but I see myself potentially walking into an interview already a nervous disaster and then just totally blowing it if they asked me a question in Spanish that I didn't quite understand. Thanks in advance!
    • By tareyng
      I am taking a gap year following my undergraduate at the University of Idaho, and applying this cycle in May of 2019. I am terrified of being denied entry, I feel that there isn't much that stands out in my application. I am doing an impressive internship this summer, but will be applying before it begins. I hope to matriculate into a surgical career, but am keeping my options open at this point. Please give me your 100% candid feedback. I'm an Idaho resident, from a medically underserved area btw. 
      cGPA: 3.54
      sGPA: 3.5
      Paid PCE: ~800 hours as a surgical floor CNA
      Unpaid PCE: 221.25 hours ED volunteer 
      Scribe Hours: 45 hours Free clinic 
      PA shadowing: 80 hours (FP, Surgical Speciality)
      MD shadowing: 15 hours (FP, Orthopedic Surgeon) 
      Volunteer hours: ~300 Muscular Dystrophy Association, Environmental, Greek 
      Definitely applying to: Northern Arizona, Samuel Merritt University, Western University of Health Sciences, Idaho State University, Cornell University, PACE University (Lenox Hill) 
      Maybe applying to: Carroll University, Salus University, Sullivan University, Albany Medical College, Touro University 
    • By hmtpnw
      This week, I am continuing my series on the most common personal statement mistakes. If you didn’t catch part one, check it out here. Below, you can find five more mistakes that applicants make when writing their personal statements.
      Writing About Something That Makes You a “Good Applicant” - Referencing being a “strong applicant” in a personal statement is not something I am a huge fan of. Your goal throughout your academic and clinical experiences should be to build a foundation that will make a better PA student and a stronger PA. It should not be about checking off boxes just because you think that it's what adcoms want to see.
      Don’t list off your extracurriculars in your personal statement, including things because you feel that they make you a “more competitive” applicant. This essay is not a resume. Instead, write about experiences that you’ve had that are central to your decision to pursue this profession, not about those that you think adcoms want to hear about.
      Addressing Difficult Topics the Wrong Way - To include or not to include… that always seems to be the question. Whether it’s bad grades, mental health issues, struggles with addiction or other life tragedy, it’s hard to know what should be addressed in a personal statement. I find that when applicants choose to include difficult topics, they focus too much on the negative without emphasizing the positive while including lots of unnecessary details. They often don’t even mention how their experience was relevant to their journey towards the PA profession at all.
      The big takeaway here is if you are going to touch on a difficult topic in your personal statement, make sure that it's an integral part of your journey before dedicating characters to it. If you have decided to include it, the best thing you can do is be concise about shortcomings/difficult subject matter/etc. Don't dwell on the negative. Instead, emphasize how you addressed the issue whether it's mental health, grades, chronic illness or whatever other issue or circumstance you experienced. Did you grow from it? Did it push you towards the profession more? Did it motivate you to change something? Explore that.
      Forcing the Reader to Read Between the Lines - I can’t tell you how many times I highlight a sentence and make the comment, “Why?” Applicants will often say something like, “Being a paramedic/scribe/MA/EMT made me want to become a PA. It was a great experience.” But, why?! What exactly was it about this experience that drove you to pursue your goal of becoming a PA? When sharing your experiences, make sure you say exactly what you want to say. Don’t force the reader to make inferences about your feelings and insights.
      Using Passive, Questioning Language - This one seems minor but it can change the entire tone of your essay.
      Let me give you an example - “Some of my grades in my undergraduate career were not stellar, but I think that with my recent successes I am likely more prepared to take on PA school. I know it will be a challenge but I feel I could be ready.” Try to avoid using terms like, “I feel… I think… Could… Would... Probably… Likely…” when projecting your future success. Be certain of yourself in your language and your tone.
      Reframing this and emphasizing some stronger language - “Although I occasionally struggled early on in my undergraduate career, my more recent successes are a reflection of my true academic ability. PA school will be a challenge, but I know that I am ready and more prepared than ever to take it on.” In this iteration, you’ve said that your recent successes are reflective of your abilities, not that “they might be.” You have said that you “know” you are prepared to handle PA school as opposed to just “thinking” you could be ready.

      Flowery Language - Last, but definitely not least, flowery language. This one is an essay killer. “The morning was crisp and bright when I stepped out my creaky, old door. I noticed the beautiful, pink rose sprouting from the green bush, covered with dew droplets on petals that were as bold and stunning as they were fragrant.” This is drowning in unnecessary descriptors. Please, don’t do this. Adcoms don’t want to read this. You probably don’t even want to read this. It’s all filler. Tell an engaging story but avoid using flowery, overly descriptive prose that says absolutely nothing while taking up an offensive amount of characters. Be concise and intentional with your writing.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to the Physician Assistant Forum! This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn More