Jump to content

Best Health Care Experience For PA School? Phlebotomist or Caregiver?

Recommended Posts

Hey everyone I just have a question about health care experience and which is best when applying to PA school. I go to Miami Dade College here in south florida, any PA's from my school that graduated will help. I am in my 2nd year of earning my bachelors in Health science with an option of physician assistant studies. I have two options which I feel I like and they Phlebotomist, and caregiver. Now I am not sure if caregiver is accepted for PA schools but I found it on the "inside pa training" website. I like caregiver because my family actually owns a nursing home and it would be great if I can get hours right at my house but I am not sure if that is also accepted for PA schools (getting hours at a family owned business I mean). I would have too check with them first but if they do agree that it is fine would being a caregiver be the best option for me? I was considering EMT but I do think the job is a little too managing for me at the moment.


I also found CNA which is also something I could do in a nursing home.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not really sure what you mean by "caregiver". I assume there is not certification involved with this, otherwise it sounds pretty similar to CNA. Every school is a little different in what they classify as PCE. For me you safe bets are EMT, Paramedic, CNA, MA, RN, RRT and Phlebotomy. Of course there are variants off this list like Corpsman and other similar military healthcare positions.

In my experience if the job requires a certification then it is typically viewed more highly in terms of PCE. EMT is a great example of this, it also gives you a huge amount of flexibility in terms of setting you can work in. This can be anything from running 911 call in an ambulance to working on a patient care floor in a hospital to working in a doctors office.

  • Upvote 2

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just from the top of my head and what I've come across from browsing this forum, phlebotomist might not qualify as PCE for some programs. It might go under HCE. EMT and CNA are definitely under PCE for most schools. You will never go wrong with EMT and CNA choice. 'Caregiver' as mentioned above sounds like a vague title. What is the job description and duties that fall under that?

Check with the programs you are considering on what they classify as PCE and HCE. That should help with making your choices. 

PS, good on you to start this early planning out for possible career in PA profession. Stay motivated and good luck. 

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree with above; not sure what "caregiver" entails, but a CNA is a great choice, and since you can do it in your family business, it would be convenient for you.  I do not believe the fact it's through your family-owned business is an issue provided you complete the hours.  A CNA job can give you great experience from the nursing side of patient care that can make you more compassionate as a PA once in practice. 

I was a phlebotomist before PA school, which gave me a great overview of different areas of the hospital and the opportunity to interact with multiple different providers, but I see the value of knowing more about healthcare from a nursing side before practicing.  You'd have to see if phlebotomy qualifies as PCE as moleashish noted though...

EMT and RRT both would require a longer certification course but would provide excellent experience, as well as maybe pay a little more as you work through school?

Best of luck to you!  


Chris Darst, PA-C


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Low end HCE: MA, CNA, phlebotomy, EMT-B (basic)

High end HCE: EMT-P (paramedic), RN, RRT would be the quickest/best health care experience prior to PA school. Now you can always do OT/PT/SLP/AT/social work/etc but that is usually for people that already have those degrees. I would not recommend doing a masters degrees in SLP to become a PA (but you can if you want to! :)) Good luck!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Similar Content

    • By enorthey
      Hey All,
      I didn't see a thread like this so I thought I would start one!  I just got a letter of rejection for the Post-Bacc Pre med program from UVA.  I applied October 1st.
    • By KarlyLM
      I’m currently taking a gap year and preparing to apply for PA school when CASPA opens up in April 2020. I have a question regarding direct patient care hours. I’ve been working as a home-health CNA for the past 3 years, racking up 2000+ hours. With that being said, I’ve always had this anxiety eating away at me that home-health CNA’s are looked down upon in the terms of what they’re able to do as opposed to CNA’s working in SNF, hospitals, etc. 
      I’m often misrepresented as a home-health aide even though I have my CNA license. I’m always afraid this will hinder me when applying to PA programs simply because I’m viewed as more of a “maid” than a healthcare professional. However, I do more CNA tasks than what people assume. I have bed ridden clients I care for, I have clients that require lifts, and I have clients that are on ventilators. On the other hand, I do have my fair share of clients that are on respite care and my time is solely spent there as a comforter and person to talk to. 
      At a recent open house for a PA school I’m interested in, I voiced my concern for this and they assured me that it’s quality over quantity and as long as I was caring for someone it would suffice them. However, that’s just one of the many schools I’m interested in. With this being said, I also have some volunteer hours working as a CNA in a free clinic in my hometown where I’m doing more of the assessing and treating PA schools are looking for. However, majority of my hours are from my CNA job. 
      I chose home health because I knew the company I was going to work for was very flexible with hours and I needed that while I was in college. I’ve been with them for so long and grew so close to patients that I haven’t thought about leaving and going to a hospital or SNF to get more/different exposure. 
      I guess my question for anyone reading this is: would you consider my home health CNA job direct patient care? 
    • By MeganPrePA
      Hello, I am a high school senior that is interested in becoming a PA. I‘m currently in the process of applying to colleges and would like to know what major would be the best for me to pursue. For a little bit of background, I had originally planned on majoring in Biology because I read that it was the most common route taken for PA school( I’m also quite fascinated with biology itself). However, after researching again, I now plan on getting a BSN so that I'll have a backup job in the medical field just in case everything doesn't go as planned. I've read that majoring in Nursing unfortunately doesn't look good because PA schools will question the student's commitment to the PA profession. Personally, I am certain that I want to become a Physician Assistant but I also want to be able to secure a job in the medical field after receiving at least my bachelors. It also seems as though the medical-related jobs that I could get with a Biology degree wouldn't be very patient care related, which is something that I wish to have in a job. Overall, I feel as though I would prosper in a more health-centered major because it relates more to my passion.
      So ultimately, my questions are:
      1. Between majoring in Biology and Nursing, which is the more advantageous route to take in order to become a PA? 
      2. Is there any true disadvantage to having a BSN when it comes to applying to PA schools? 
      3. Are there any other majors that would be a better choice to study than Biology or Nursing?
      I would greatly appreciate it if anyone can get help me out!
    • By sacharle
      There is an awesome organization called ThePAC (Physician Assistants of Color) that holds diversity events in multiple cities across the U.S. The next one will be in Detroit, Michigan on September 28, 2019. The event is a great opportunity for all three levels of the profession! https://www.eventbrite.com/e/thepac-takes-detroit-tickets-70091765357
      Pre-PAs get to talk directly to program directors from the local/surrounding region (this event will have 7), and get specific advice about their application profile from programs directly as well as experienced PA students and PA-Cs. 
      PA-S  and PA-C get to fraternize and network with each other as well as tap into resources such as job recruiters, financial advisors, and transition to practice information. 
      There are always lots of giveaways such as medical equipment, PANCE/PANRE prep, discounts on scrub companies, and more. 
      This event is open to any and everyone no matter the race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, etc. 
      If you cannot attend this event, give them a follow on IG @thepa.c or FB 'Physician Assistants of Color' so you can get notified of when the next event/location will be. 

  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to the Physician Assistant Forum! This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn More