Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
stephenpac

PA School Ranking by PANCE Pass Rates

Recommended Posts

Since 1998 US News has been publishing the only known ranking of PA programs.

 

Their rankings are based on subjective peer assessment surveys of PA program faculty. 

 

A useful ranking system should be “measurable, reproducible, and not opinion based!

 

Physician Assistant Programs Ranked by PANCE Pass Rates 2017

 

http://www.thepalife.com/best-pa-schools/

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So, does this also account for variables such as attrition rates and other obstacles that may be encountered by PA students? I had one person get a divorce which ultimately made it too difficult for them to study and pass their first time. Eventually they ended up passing months later but real life happens. We had students who were in their 50s and one was 60 years old when they graduated our class, clearly they struggled to pass their first time as well but they would make great clinicians once in the work force.

 

I think this is an important metric but not the be all for rankings as I'm perceiving that you are suggesting.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

YES, pance rates are important and you have to pass pance to practice, but, given that the vast majority of students pass pance I think any criteria has to include variety and quality of rotation sites. have all the sites and preceptors been stable for at least 5 years? Do the students report that they are allowed to see patients and do procedures as opposed to just following a doc around for 4-6 weeks, etc.

 

In general, I think the older , more established programs(ie duke, stony brook, drexel, yale, emory, u. WA, U. Iowa, etc) will give you a better educational experience than the university of just opened last week and struggling to find anyone with a pulse to precept our students. I've heard horror stories about the poor quality of rotation sites at new programs; students being used as MAs, students not allowed to see patients or do procedures, gyn rotations in which students can't do pelvics, etc

  • Upvote 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I prefer this method:

 

In an article titled: A Novel Approach to Ranking Physician Assistant

Programs (2010 Vol 21 No 4/The Journal of Physician Assistant

Education, by James Van Rhee, MS, PA-C; Michael J. Davanzo, MMS,

PA-C), a new approach to ranking PA programs was proposed based on

objective data.

 

PA program directors from 126 accredited PA programs (at the time)

identified indicators to include in a new ranking system for PA programs.

 

The four criteria they agreed upon were:

 

1. Each program’s current ARC-PA accreditation length

2. Student-to-faculty ratio

3. Percentage of faculty with doctoral degrees

4. Most recent 5-year average PANCE rates

If you

 

The top programs did not match US News

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

I prefer this method:
 
In an article titled: A Novel Approach to Ranking Physician Assistant
Programs (2010 Vol 21 No 4/The Journal of Physician Assistant
Education, by James Van Rhee, MS, PA-C; Michael J. Davanzo, MMS,
PA-C), a new approach to ranking PA programs was proposed based on
objective data.
 
PA program directors from 126 accredited PA programs (at the time)
identified indicators to include in a new ranking system for PA programs.
 
The four criteria they agreed upon were:
 
1. Each program’s current ARC-PA accreditation length
2. Student-to-faculty ratio
3. Percentage of faculty with doctoral degrees
4. Most recent 5-year average PANCE rates
If you
 
The top programs did not match US News

 

Here is a link. It will immediately download.

 

shp.rutgers.edu/dept/primary_care/paweb/documents/NovelRankingSystem.pdf

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Stressedanddepressed
      Hello everyone, I am currently in my second semester of my didactic year. I struggled so much my first semester and ended up having to remediate one class. I feel like I retained nothing from my first semester and can barely recall things. I get so anxious everyday over my future . I have no idea how to face my family if I do fail. Also it would really crush me because this is what I've been working towards for the past 3 years since I graduated high school.  Compared to my other classmates I feel like I know the least. Living in fear everyday is really getting to me emotionally and I don't know what to do.
    • By magboo
      So I finally got a job at my dream hospital!! I am currently working there as a Patient Care Technician/ PCT. However, I will be leaving for PA school next year. I really want to return to this hospital and work as a PA! The problem is that getting a job at my hospital is super competitive. Is there a way for me to ensure/ increase my chances of getting a PA job in this facility in the future?
       
      (Also, what do you guys think of requesting a absense of leave instead of quitting? Can I be able to come back to the hospital to pursue a higher position?)

      Thanks in advance!
    • By chloepilgrim
      Hi There,
      I am in the process of a career switch and I was wondering what everyone thought my chances are of getting into a PA program.
      I graduated undergrad with a BA in psychology and a BS in neuroscience. In undergrad, I tutored Biology for a year. 
      My cumulative GPA was 3.5 and science GPA is 3.1 (I got C's organic chemistry + lab, and biochemistry + lab)
      I thought I wanted to become a researcher and so I entered a Neuroscience PhD program. Though after a year I decided I wanted to pursue a clinical route (research is too lonely) and switched into a Pharmacology Masters Program. I graduated with a graduate GPA of 3.2 and have taken classes such as physiology, gross anatomy (cadaver dissection) lotssss of pharmacology classes, neuroscience/psychology courses, and a very intense Neurology course alongside medical students.
      I also graduated with 5.5 years of research experience and a thesis that is *hopefully* going to be published.
      I am currently a medical assistant and plan on doing about 3000 patient contact hours before applying to PA school. I was wondering what the chances are of me getting into a PA program even though my graduate GPA is quite low and my undergraduate science GPA is also low.
      Thanks
    • By sacharle
      There is an awesome organization called ThePAC (Physician Assistants of Color) that holds diversity events in multiple cities across the U.S. The next one will be in Detroit, Michigan on September 28, 2019. The event is a great opportunity for all three levels of the profession! https://www.eventbrite.com/e/thepac-takes-detroit-tickets-70091765357
      Pre-PAs get to talk directly to program directors from the local/surrounding region (this event will have 7), and get specific advice about their application profile from programs directly as well as experienced PA students and PA-Cs. 
      PA-S  and PA-C get to fraternize and network with each other as well as tap into resources such as job recruiters, financial advisors, and transition to practice information. 
      There are always lots of giveaways such as medical equipment, PANCE/PANRE prep, discounts on scrub companies, and more. 
      This event is open to any and everyone no matter the race, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, etc. 
      If you cannot attend this event, give them a follow on IG @thepa.c or FB 'Physician Assistants of Color' so you can get notified of when the next event/location will be. 


    • By jennnrenaeee
      How long does it take the schools to recieve the GRE scores after you’ve taken the test?
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to the Physician Assistant Forum! This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn More