Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Hello,

 

I'm starting down the path to become a P.A. and have a few questions I cannot find answers for here.

 

1) If one has a strong interest in pursuing EM, would it be advisable to delay starting PA school to earn an EMT-P over a simple EMT-B or can the skills learned in paramedic training be easily gained through a residency or on-the-job? I am an EMT-B and could become a paramedic in 1.5 years or else apply 1.5 years sooner. I want to be prepared to practice at the highest level in EM one day in the far future so the delay would be worth it if necessary.

 

2) Does PA School ranking matter for jobs? For residency competitiveness? For future academic endeavors? For respect on the job?

 

3) How is California as a market for PAs? I have no interest in living elsewhere. It's California or bust. Is this going to be a problem (I'm fine with taking pay cut to be here, just want to make sure I won't have to move to the east God forbid.)

 

 

Thanks everyone!

Link to post
Share on other sites

1.) Would a employer prefer past experience as a EMT-P over EMT-B? Sure. Does it have as great of impact as you think? Probably not. The PA that I know worked as a CNA before PA school and then went straight into EM after graduation. Impressing your EM preceptor would yield much more advantage opportunity for a EM job than becoming a EMT-P vs EMT-B.

 

2.) I'm assuming you're referring to the USNews rankings? Those ranks mean nothing and are based off things that do not matter. Things that do matter include PANCE scores, quality of clinical rotations, the age of the program, and what graduates of the program have to say about the school. No intelligent company or physician is going to look at these and deny your request for employment and/or residency.

 

3.) I don't have anything to contribute to this question, sorry.

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I have to say I have a hard time believing that school ranking doesn't matter for residency. As I understand it, residency is somewhat competitive. I know in Dr. World that med school reputation does play a role as some residency programs take applicants from top tier schools. Now if the rankings don't correllate to school reputation, that would be annoying, because rankings should really just be a proxy for th above mentioned relevant criteria.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I have to say I have a hard time believing that school ranking doesn't matter for residency. As I understand it, residency is somewhat competitive. I know in Dr. World that med school reputation does play a role as some residency programs take applicants from top tier schools. Now if the rankings don't correllate to school reputation, that would be annoying, because rankings should really just be a proxy for th above mentioned relevant criteria.

 

And yet... they don't matter, and only somewhat correlate.

Link to post
Share on other sites

As a PA student, you have many opportunities to excel to the point of getting a good residency. Many schools have optional rotations, including some that you can -- if you want -- help set up for yourself. Take ones that would support your residency if you already know what you want to do.

 

Preceptors write evaluations and can, if they are impressed with your effort, lend their recommendations to your residency applications. Many schools also have Pi Alpha, the PA student honor society, which can accept only a certain percentage of a given school's graduates. That can look good on your record. You'll have faculty members who can also write recommendations. And so forth. So, between all of this, you have many chances to succeed as a student in PA school.

 

No one really cared all that much about which high school and undergraduate college/university you attended when it came time to apply to PA school. Assume that applying for a residency (still, by the way, the exception rather than the rule for new PA graduates) will be pretty much the same.

 

Pick the PA school that you feel will give you the best chance at being successful, during your didactic time, your clinical time, and when you sit for the PANCE. Put in the effort you need to and then let life take care of itself.

 

Steady as she goes.

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...

NPR just did a piece on how school rankings influence the people who apply.  Social pressures to apply to a top ranked program tend to push exclusivity rates up which completes a cycle...it's more economic than anything else.  Ranking may matter for jobs if you graduate from a program which has that Ive League, good ole boy's club connections, but this is not something you can rely on, unless your family contributes to the school or your dad is a former dean.

 

PA school is extremely competetive, just apply broadly and early, and take what you get.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just worry about getting into PA school.  School rankings are next to meaningless in this field.  Going for an EMT-P seems like a waste of time, if it's going to delay your application to PA school.  If it's something you want to do for you, fine, I understand how it could be a valuable and personally enriching experience, but not a necessary one for your desired endstate.  Understand that you will learn how to be an EMPA in the ED (either on the job or in residency).  Consider that thousands of excellent emergency medicine physicians have no background as an EMT, much less as a paramedic.  In many ways, they are very different jobs, with paramedics being very prehospital focused, whereas the ED is much more "team" oriented, and with many more diagnostic and therapeutic capabilities available.  

  • Upvote 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Similar Content

    • By Tarantino
      Hi, everyone. I'm a non-traditional student, wrapping up my associate's degree in psychology from a small state school (not a community college) in Georgia. This college only offers 3 bachelor degrees, which is why I would finish elsewhere. I was a student at Arizona State Online, but transferred to take my prerequisites and labs in person. All my science prerequisites with in-person labs for PA programs will be done prior to transferring to the next college for my bachelor's degree. Now that I'm almost done, I was originally planning to then finish my degree through ASU, but am now considering finishing it at my local university for various reasons. Here's the two options I have:
       
      Option A: Finish my bachelor's degree in psychology at my local university.
      PROS: Graduate with less than $10k in debt. Get hands-on experience in research. More than likely get a stronger letter of recommendation.
      CONS: It would take longer to finish. I would barely get by, working part-time and living paycheck to paycheck. I would have to devote more time to in-person classes, which would take away from my income and time to do other things. Less volunteer hours. ALL clinical hours will be in private EMS, so my hands-on experience and skills won't be utilized as much, as it's 95% mostly transporting stable patients.
      Option B: Finish my bachelor's degree in psychology at Arizona State University (online).
      PROS: Accelerated program and can finish in 1.5 years instead of 2.5 years. Work in 911 EMS, which means better hands-on experience and utilizing my skills more - I think this will also make me a better provider in the future. More time to work, which means more income. More time not in a physical class, which means more time to volunteer, which is less stressful since I also have more money in general. Still get to go graduate in person.
      CONS: Graduate with around $30k in debt. Weaker letters of recommendation. Little research opportunity. Obvious I finished my degree online because the college is 20+ hours away.
       
      Although it would cost more to finish at ASU, I could become a PA faster, which means it would actually be better financially IF I were to get into both at the same cycle.
    • By Erose
      Hello all!
      I am sure there are already several similar topics already on here, but I am struggling to find them. I am wondering if anyone has compiled a list of schools that do or do not accept online anatomy and physiology courses if taken during quarantine. I have checked the websites of several schools that make no statements on how their prereq requirements have been altered in response to the pandemic. If anyone has any recommendations I would be very grateful.
      Thank you!!
    • By beccapolyack
      Hey, everybody! Fairly new here. I’ve been scrolling through other threads on this site regarding recommended online schools for prerequisite courses. A few of the threads are extremely helpful but several years old, so I wanted to start a more contemporary thread in case online school qualities have changed or there are any new ones. 
      I’m looking to take biochemistry and anatomy online. Ideally a low price would be great, but a self-paced online course is most important to me considering my current career and associated time restrictions. 
      I’ve been looking heavily at UNE for both courses but have heard mixed reviews. Any recommendations or suggestions based on your experiences, for UNE or others?
      Thank you so much!
      Becca
    • By MACSID
      I am finishing up an 8 week session of Medical Terminology and Biochemistry with Doane online this week.  I will start another 8 week session in January that will consist of BIOX 355 (Human anatomy) and BIOX 356 (Human Physiology).  Has anyone taken these 2 classes at the same time (not to be confused with A&P I or II)?  I'm wondering if it will be much more difficult than the current 8 week session with Biochem.  The professors are Eggert and McMillin for the next 2 classes.  I'm hoping I'm not the only one crazy enough to do both full classes in 8 weeks.  Tell me it's doable!
    • By trusttheprocess95
      Hello all!
      Has anyone taken Pharmacology online at Doane? I'm exploring my options, but leaning more towards Doane University at the moment. ANY type of feedback regarding the course or other schools ya'll may have completed it at would be greatly APPRECIATED! 
      Thank you so much in advance 
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Welcome to the Physician Assistant Forum! This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Learn More