"You have to kiss a lot of frogs in order to know which one is a prince."
I have read this great article that talks about how you are destined to the perfect school that fit you.
From my experience I got rejected from a school (it might be the same school as you) on my second time application for a lame excuse after I was waitlisted in that same school the previous year.
I felt bad at first, but this article made sense. I was accepted to a better school with friendlier faculty and students, a great curriculum that cares about students’ success, and the cherry on top I received a scholarship. Now I say Thank God I was rejected from that other school, the program was not a good fit for me. After all I am a believe in fate :)
My advise to you do not submit your TOFEL scores, if you got your B.S from the U.S. I never submitted mine.
Keep the faith.